比较AWS、Azure函数和Google函数

Question

我想通过选择aws、azure函数或google云功能来开发一个无服务器的项目。然后，我想比较每一个，以便为我的项目选择最好的一个。

我需要为我的项目选择最稳定的无服务器技术。

有没有比较这些技术的材料？

这些无服务器技术是否有支持的框架？

Answer 1

比较AWS、Azure函数和Google函数

1. 支持的语言 AWS lambda- Node.js，Python，Java，C# (.net核心) Azure函数- Node.js，Node.js，F#，C#，batch，bash 谷歌云功能 Node.js
2. 每个请求的最大执行时间 AWS lambda- 300秒(5分) Azure功能- 300秒(5分) 谷歌云功能 540秒(9分钟)
3. 日志管理 AWS lambda-云表 Azure函数- Azure存储 谷歌云功能云日志记录
4. 可伸缩性与可用性 AWS lambda-自动缩放 Azure函数 -Automatic缩放 谷歌云功能自动缩放
5. HTTP端点 AWS - API网关 Azure函数 -HTTP触发器 Google函数 HTTP触发器
6. 定价 注:这些是每次通话费用.CPU和RAM时间的收费是常见的，通常超过每次通话费用，应该考虑. AWS lambda-0.20美元/10万次处决 Azure函数-0.20美元/10万次执行 Google函数$0.40/M执行，没有额外的HTTP 定价细节
7. 函数极限 AWS -Unlimited函数 Azure函数-Unlimited函数 谷歌云功能 1,000每个项目
8. 并发执行 AWS -每个区域每个帐户并行执行100次，但用户可以增加它 Azure函数 -No极限 谷歌云功能 HTTP无限制，1,000个非HTTP
9. Deployments AWS -Zip，AWS-S3或编辑代码内联 Azure函数-Anything an Azure WebApp可以处理: FTP(S)、KUDU、部署、One Drive\DropBox、Git\Local \TFS\etc、Visual \XCode\Eclipse\etc、PowerShell\Cli\可能所有SDK的 Google函数 CLI、ZIP上载、内联web编辑器、云存储或云源存储库

每一个人都欢迎更正信息并添加新的信息。

Answer 2

AWS Lambda对Azure函数与Google函数

以下是由不同云供应商提供的所有无服务器特性的聚合。这是基于我的观点。

如果在一段时间内有任何变化，或者您想要添加任何新的内容，请随时评论，并让它来跟踪不同的功能。

+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
|     Category    | AWS Lambda          |    Azure              | Google Cloud      |
|                 |                     |  Functions            |  Functions        |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 1. Version      | Production ready    | Preview - Beta        | Closed Alpha      |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 2. Supported    | Nodejs, Python,     | Nodejs, Python,       | Javascript        |
| Languages       |      Java           |   PHP, F#, C#         |                   |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 3. Dependency   | Compile all         | Using                 | Using             |
| Management      | external packages   | package.json – nodejs | package.json      |
|                 | and zip the         | project.json – F#,C#  |                   |
|                 | source code         |                       |                   |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
|                 | S3, DynamoDB        | Bindings/Triggers     | HTTP              |
|                 | Kinesis             |                       | functions:        |
|                 | Streams             | Scheduler             | Http Triggers     |
|                 | SNS, SES            | Http(webhook)         | Webhooks (drive,  |
|                 | Cognito             | Azure Storage         |  gmail, calendar) |
|                 | Cloud Formation     | Events Hubs           |                   |
| 4. Event        | Cloud Watch         | Queues, Tables        | Background        |
| Sources         | Code Commit         | DocumentDB(No-sql)    | functions:        |
|                 | Scheduled Events    | Notification Hub      | Cloud Pub/Sub,    |
|                 | Config              | Twilio                | Cloud Storage     |
|                 | Echo,               |                       |                   |
|                 | Alexa               |                       | Pub/Sub:          |
|                 | APIGateway          |                       | Cloud Logging     |
|                 |                     |                       | Gmail, Twilio     |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 5. Granular     | IAM                 |                       |                   |
|  IAM            | policy              | Not Yet               | Not Yet           |
|                 | can be Attached     |                       |                   |
|                 | to Lambda.          |                       |                   |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
|                 | - On top of Linux   | - On top of Windows   |                   |
| 6. Architecture | - Memory allocated  | - Memory allocated    |                   |
|                 |    per function.    |    per app service.   | Not Specified     |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
|                 | No persistent       | Env variables         |                   |
|                 |  storage.           | can be set in         |                   |
| 7. Persistent   | Completely          | App services          | Not Specified     |
|  Storage        | Stateless           | which can be used     |                   |
|                 |                     | in functions.         |                   |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 8. HTTP         | APIGateway          | HTTP webhooks         | HTTP Trigger      |
| Endpoint        |                     |                       |                   |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 9. Log          | Cloud               | Kudu Console          | Stackdriver       |
| Management      | watch               |                       | Logging           |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 10. Maximum     | 300 seconds         | No limit              | No limit          |
| Execution       | (5 mins)            |                       |                   |
| Time            |                     |                       |                   |
| per request     |                     |                       |                   |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 11. Concurrent  | 100                 | 10 instances          | Not Specified     |
| Executions      | parallel            | which is several      |                   |
|                 | Executions, but     | 100 executions        |                   |
|                 | Can be increased    |                       |                   |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 12. Deployment  | Zip upload          | Git, dropbox,         | Zip upload,       |
|                 | to Lambda/s3,       | visual studio,        | Cloud Storage,    |
|                 | Serverless          | One drive,            | Cloud Source      |
|                 | Framework           | Kudu Console          | repositories,     |
|                 |                     |                       | Git               |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 13. Maximum     |                     |                       | 20 functions      |
|     no. of      | No limit            | Not Specified         | per project       |
|  Functions      |                     |                       |                   |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+
| 14. Pricing     | Request Charges:    | Request Charges:      | Unknown until     |
|                 | $0.20 / 1M requests | $0.20 / 1M requests   | Open beta         |
|                 |                     |                       |                   |
|                 | Compute Charges:    | Compute Charges:      |                   |
|                 | $0.00001667 / GB-s  | $0.000008 / GB-s      |                   |
+-----------------+---------------------+-----------------------+-------------------+

Answer 3

更新情况很少(2017年2月18日)：

• Azure函数具有GA-ed 2016
• AWS支持C#，但只支持.NET核心
• 您可以拥有多达100个Azure函数-Apps，每个应用程序都可以包含多个函数。
• Azure函数消耗层当前每个函数调用有300秒最大运行时。
• Azure函数计算价格在GA上已经从$0.000008 / GB-s更新到$0.00001667 / GB-s。